Formula 1
Why F1 is desperate for a plan to fix self-inflicted qualifying woes
A successful idea has many fathers, a failure is an orphan.
Edited: Mar 19, 2016, 2:02 PM
Copy link
Share on Viber

Motorsport Blog
Motorsport Blog
A successful idea has many fathers, a failure is an orphan.
That was never more true than the new elimination style qualifying which took place in Melbourne today at the Australian Grand Prix with almost universal disapproval.
It is hard to decide which was the more unedifying spectacle - no cars on track for several minutes at the end of the session, where normally the session builds to a thrilling climax; or the key stakeholders who voted for it, reversing out and taking no responsibility for what is clearly a disastrous idea.
It is strange to see action in a sport as mature as this, which just doesn't feel like F1. Yet that was the effect of this new format, in the final session. Damon Hill observed that it was a unique situation, whereby pole sitter Lewis Hamilton could get out of his car and have time to wave the chequered flag himself to end the session. Sebastian Vettel became the first driver in living memory to attend the press conference immediately after the session in team gear, not overalls.
One suspects he was making a point.

As for the risk of experimenting in public with new formats, which have not been completely thought through, Vettel put it best when he said, "There’s a certain responsibility.. We can’t just try things that many of us criticise, us included. You can’t just turn around and say 'It was the wrong thing,' we need to be sensible and try to do the right change (in the first place)."
The fact is that at the second Barcelona test at the start of this month, the FIA's Charlie Whiting met with the sporting director level managers from each team. This is the group that really gets things done in F1, people like Jonathan Wheatley of Red Bull, Ron Meadows of Mercedes and Steve Neilsen at Williams. They told Whiting that the first two parts of qualifying would be okay, but warned that in the final part, the cars would go out early to set their time on new tyres and in all likelihood that would be it for the spectacle.
The consensus view being briefed informally by those in that meeting that week among that group, as reported on this site during the test, was that the new qualifying format would feature elimination in Q1 and Q2, but then the old format for the final part of qualifying.
Somewhere between going back from that meeting and the final vote last Thursday, nine days before qualifying in Melbourne, the sensible plan was abandoned at the higher levels and instead the sport opened itself up to the inevitable embarrassment.
So the question now is, what will the sport do next? The team bosses are meeting in the Melbourne paddock to discuss the matter, with some suggesting that the most obvious route is to revert to the old system.
There are three options as we see it.

1. Go back to the old format
The most dramatic solution in many ways would be to abandon the idea of elimination altogether and go back to qualifying as it was in recent seasons.
Bernie Ecclestone had suggested reversing the top ten, but settled on this compromise of elimination. He was keen to see a change, because Mercedes are too strong,
"If we go back to the old system, I tell you what would happen: Mercedes would be first and second," he told Autosport after the session. "Pretty simple. What I don't want to see is where you and I could predict how the grid is going to be for the start of a race, and how that race is going to finish."
The timing systems have been reworked in recent weeks by Ecclestone's FOM staff at Biggin Hill; many sleepless nights to get it ready in time and there would be pressure to re-code it before Bahrain if the decision was made to axe elimination altogether. But it could be done. Judging from social media, this would be the most popular option with fans.
2. Go back to the Sporting Directors' plan, mixing the old and the new
The plan hatched in Barcelona among the Sporting Directors and Whiting would maintain the first two parts of elimination qualifying, but then revert to a shoot-out of 8 or 10 cars for 10 minutes, as in the past.
This would have the effect of making the less interesting parts of the session more dramatic, but maintain the integrity of the battle for pole position. There were many operational mistakes made by teams in Q1 and Q2 that they would be less likely to make next time, after they have had a chance to analyse and review this session. That would probably result in a more dramatic Q1 and Q2 session, where reversals like Jolyon Palmer making it through to Q2 at the expense of Marcus Ericsson would be more commonplace.

3. Keep the new format but extend the elimination period and cut the final session to a five minute sprint
One of the most non-sensical things about the new format was that it introduced real pressure onto the teams and the drivers in the first two sessions, but then there was no pressure in Q3 after the first run; apart from Rosberg needing a second run to get ahead of the Ferrari, no-one had any incentive to do anything.
Fourteen minutes is too long for the final session of eight cars, where they all go at once. So give the drivers one final blast on a new set of the softest tyres to see who can go the fastest. If you make a mistake, there's no time to rectify it. Meanwhile, the 90 seconds isn't long enough for the elimination, as Gutierrez showed. When a lap takes 92 seconds or more, it's too restrictive, so elimination every two minutes would be better.
A vote will be needed to make any changes, but a plan needs to be put in place to make any change - even if it is back to the old system - given the on again-off again way in which it was implemented in the first place.
The other question is why this scenario has played out as it has. Is it just very poor planning and a dysfunctional rule making process between the teams, FIA and FOM, or is there something darker at work here, aimed at creating embarrassment in certain quarters?
The reaction from the stakeholders and who drives the next move will tell us a great deal.
What would you do next with F1 qualifying?
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?
Take our 5 minute survey.
- The Motorsport.com Team
Read and post comments
Read also :
Share Or Save This Story
Copy link
Share on Viber
Previous article Steiner says Haryanto incident "not too clever"
Next article Traffic to blame for Q1 exit - Kvyat
Top Comments
There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?
View More & Comment
Latest news

Hollywood star Christian Bale wants to portray MotoGP’s “gods” in a movie
MotoGP
MGP MotoGP
Portuguese GP
55 min
Hollywood star Christian Bale wants to portray MotoGP’s “gods” in a movie

Marc Marquez's body felt "stiffer" in Portimao practice: "I’m the only one who can lose”
MotoGP
MGP MotoGP
Portuguese GP
58 min
Marc Marquez's body felt "stiffer" in Portimao practice: "I’m the only one who can lose”

'Marco Bezzecchi is fastest at Portimao,' says Alex Marquez - after going fastest
MotoGP
MGP MotoGP
Portuguese GP
1 h
'Marco Bezzecchi is fastest at Portimao,' says Alex Marquez - after going fastest

Formula 1 set for V8 turbo return in 2030
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
2 h
Formula 1 set for V8 turbo return in 2030
Feature
Discover prime content

Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Formula 1
By Kevin Turner
Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
You have 2 options:
- Become a subscriber.
- Disable your adblocker.
Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here
Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page
Manage Alerts
Subscribe


